how to be a fake Christian

An article over at CNN, More Teens Becoming “Fake” Christians, raises news that is alarming but not new.*

According to Princeton Professor Kenda Dean, author of Almost Christian, American teenagers are embracing what she calls “moralistic therapeutic deism,” looking to God as a divine therapist whose primary function is to make us feel good about ourselves.

She places the blame for this squarely and fairly on parents and pastors. “”Churches don’t give them enough to be passionate about,” she says. And she’s right.

But my concern is that she never defines what Christian is. She critiques a “gospel of niceness” that doesn’t require teens to take risk, witness or make sacrifices.

But quite frankly, that’s not what a Christian is either. I can join Peta and do that. Being a Christian isn’t about the sacrifices I make, but about the one Christ made.

The teens who are most articulate about their faith, she says, are the Mormons and the evangelicals. But neither group, ultimately, accepts the definition of being a Christian that the other holds, so each, I suppose, could consider the other group fake Christians as well. That’s why definitions are important.

Being a Christian is not about being passionate or articulate, although of course it doesn’t exclude it. And that’s my concern about a study of fake Christians that doesn’t define what a Christian is.

Her remedy, by the way, is for parents to do something radical. Here’s how CNN reports it:

Get “radical,” Dean says.
She says parents who perform one act of radical faith in front of their children convey more than a multitude of sermons and mission trips.
A parent’s radical act of faith could involve something as simple as spending a summer in Bolivia working on an agricultural renewal project or turning down a more lucrative job offer to stay at a struggling church, Dean says.
But it’s not enough to be radical — parents must explain “this is how Christians live,” she says.

I agree. But parents also must explain what Christians are, broken, fallen creatures in need of grace and reconciliation through Christ.

Even radical obedience may bring glory to ourselves or to our church, without ever bringing glory to God.

That’s fake Christianity by any measure.


The Almost Christian, by John Wesley
The Almost Christian, by George Whitefield
Almost a Christian, by Matthew Meade

3 thoughts on “how to be a fake Christian”

  1. My grandmother thought I was a fake Christian even as a small child because my parents converted to the Episcopal church and had me baptized in a baptismal font rather than by complete immersion as was her tradition. According to her definition of Christian, you couldn’t be one if you weren’t sopping wet from head to toe. So it bothers me greatly that ANYONE, even a Princeton professor, has the nerve to suggest that she has all the answers of what it means to be a “real” Christian, and everyone else is “fake” or “almost”. There are lots of former Mormons who will tell you they believe that the LDS church isn’t real Christianity, yet the author sites this denomination as having more “real” Christian youth. I question the integrity of any Christian who claims to be able to pass judgment on another person’s Christianity.

  2. The sentence “Even radical obedience may bring glory to ourselves or to our church, without ever bringing glory to God.” . Is so true. God cannot be fully glorified through us unless knowledge of him in words is given to people. What he has done for us, what he is doing for us, and what he can do for others. Zeal needs to point to God for his glory. And the best way to do that is to have zeal with actions and words of truth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s